Melted witch treat bags are fun to make for kids of all ages. With the free Halloween treat bag printable, a paper witch hat craft and some green play dough or slime, you will have the best no-candy goody to give! This also works great as a school giveaway since it is food-free and safe for those with food allergies.

Halloween No-Candy Treat Idea with orange and write printables — I love that this treat looks like a melted witch! It makes me want to watch Wizard of Oz again.

DIY Melted Witch Treat Bags

Here’s another great alternative to Halloween candy! This sure is a cute witch Halloween treat that your kids will enjoy for weeks after October 31st. I like these melted witch treat bags because they make me laugh. I can almost hear the witch screaming in the background…I am melting! Click here to get your free printable Halloween treat bag tags:

Related: Another no-candy idea is DIY Halloween soap & Easy Melting Beads Ideas & Projects to Create with Children

This article contains affiliate links.

Make Homemade Green Play Dough

The first thing to do is to make the green play dough that will go into the plastic bags which is our melted witch.

Supplies Needed to Make Green Play Dough

1 cup flour
1/2 cup salt
2 tsp cream of tartar
1 tbsp vegetable oil
1 cup warm water
1 box of lime jello

How to Make Green Play Dough

Step 1

Mix all the dry ingredients in a medium sauce pan.

Step 2

Add oil and water.

Step 3

Cook over medium heat.

Step 4

Mix until it turns doughy.

Step 5

After 5 minutes it will be hard to mix so remove it before that time.

Step 6

Let it cool and place on a lightly floured surface.

Step 7

Knead. Store in fridge.

Make Melted Witch Halloween Favors

Supplies Needed for Favors

Plastic Baggies
Black Construction paper
Printable – see below
Green Play Dough from recipe or purchased
Tape
Scissors

Video: How to Make Melted Witch Favors

Step 1

Place your play dough in a baggie and flatten it out.

The witches hat made out of black construction paper. — The hat is so easy to make, but looks fantastic.

Step 2

Make the hat using black construction paper. For each witches hat:

Cut a small circle for a brim.
Cut a larger 1/2 circle that you fold into a cone and tape onto the brim of the hat.
Glue both pieces and tape over your green jello play dough.

Halloween Printable Tags with cursive writing — I love how eloquent this writing looks. It’s lovely!

Step 3

Add your cute little note “Witching You A Happy Halloween!” on a some fun paper and tape to the inside of the hat.

This is a bag of green "melted witch" with an orange and white gift card. — “I’m meeeeeelting!”

Step 4

Put it all together and give it as a gift!

We will definitely be making more of these for my son’s class. The little ones will love such a practical gift and the parents will be happy that it’s not more sugar!

Witch Treat Bags for Halloween

Make these super cute Halloween melting witch treat bags for kids of all ages. They're the perfect party favor for Halloween parties and a great alternative to candy.

Materials

Green Play Dough
1 cup flour
1/2 cup salt
2 tsp cream of tartar
1 tbsp vegetable oil
1 cup warm water
1 box of lime jello
Melted Witch Halloween Favor
Plastic Baggies
Black Construction paper
Printable – see below
Green Play Dough from recipe or purchased
Tape
Scissors

Instructions

Green Play Dough Recipe

1.Mix all the dry ingredients in a medium sauce pan.

2. Add oil and water.

3. Cook over medium heat.

4. Mix until it turns doughy.

5. After 5 minutes it will be hard to mix so remove it before that time.

6. Let it cool and place on a lightly floured surface.

7. Knead. Store in fridge.

Melted Witch Halloween Party Favor Instructions

1. Place your play dough in a baggie and flatten it out.

2. Make the hat using black construction paper. For each witches hat:

Cut a small circle for a brim.
Cut a larger 1/2 circle that you fold into a cone and tape onto the brim of the hat.
Glue both pieces and tape over your green jello play dough.

3. Add your cute little note “Witching You A Happy Halloween!” on a some fun paper and tape to the inside of the hat.

4. Put it all together and give it as a gift!