Grab a package of Nutter Butters and some candy, frosting, and sprinkles and let your kids go to town creating any of these 13 Nutter Butter Cookie Crafts. These edible crafts  are so much fun to create and  would be a great project to do at a scout meeting, for a class party, or for an afternoon snack.

Well then, check out all these fantastic ideas for transforming ordinary store bought cookies into fun treats!

This article contains affiliate links.

Nutter Butter Cookie Crafts
Fun Nutty Butter Recipes!

1. Pink Fuzzy Slipper Cookies

Have you ever thought to turn a Nutter Butter into Pink Fuzzy Slipper Cookies, puppies, horses or frogs?

2. Chocolate Nutter Butter Penguins

It doesn’t have to be snowing outside to make some adorable Dark Chocolate Nutter Butter Penguins using candy eyes, circus peanut  beaks and feat, and Tootsie Roll wings. Such a cute food craft idea from Hungry Happenings!

3. Yummy Cute Horse Food Craft

Give your Nutter Butters a dunk in some CandiQuik and add a few simple candy decorations and you’ve transformed your cookies into handsome  horses.

4. Cool Butter Nutter Frogs

Bright green dipped cookies can easily be decorated to look like frogs, like these ones from Mommy Style. Once kissed they may not turn into a prince, but they sure will taste great.

5. Creepy Crawlie Bugs

If you want to create some creepy crawlers, how about adding a few pretzel legs and candy eyes to turn your cookies into bugs, like these from Betty Crocker?

6. Cute Nutter Butter Puppies

Hungry Happenings may not have the ability to bring home a real puppy, but your kids will love making some  Nutter Butter Puppies, using caramel ears, chocolate chip nose, and candy eyes.

7. Adorable Olaf Food Craft

Olaf couldn’t be more adorable, unless of course, he’s made out of a Nutter Butter cookie. Thanks to This Mama Loves for this cute idea!

8. Wise and Cute Owl Food Craft

Kids will love adding squiggly wings and candy eyes to Nutter Butter cookies to make easy owls from Double Fun Parties.

9. Cool Swarm of Bees Food Craft

No one wants to have a bunch of bees swarm around them, unless those bees are sweet cookies with sugar coated cookie wings, like these ones from Krazy In The Kitchen.

10. Sweet and Cute Nutty Butter Hippos

Cindy Eckhart made the easiest cookie craft that even young kids can make by adding a few round pieces of cereal to create nostrils and ears and two candy eyes: Nutter Butter  Hippos!

11. Nutty Butter Ice Cream Food Craft

Want an ice cream cone that won’t melt? Try this one from Drug Store Divas. A Nutter Butter dipped in a bit of white candy coating topped with some sprinkles and a candy cherry on top is a great alternative.

12. Lovely Yummy Owls

Older kids can help handcraft beautiful owls out of the peanut butter cookies using candy melts and heart shaped sprinkles. Follow the steps from My Mommy Style!

13. Nutty Butter Polar Bears

If you are more into cute and cuddly, it’s easy to transform Nutter Butters into polar bears with chocolate chip noses and mini chip eyes. Such a cute treat from Hungry Happenings!

Other Fun Activities with Cookies from Kids Activities Blog

Which Nutty Butter cookie idea are you making with your kiddos first?

You Might Also Like

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *